The first round of questions has come and gone, and now Sarah is faced with the first of many excruciatingly hard decisions. There are six contestants, and Sarah only has four roses to give out. Who will she choose? To make sure she chooses the right men, Sarah takes a look at each contestants’ response and gives here opinions:

Daniel Ewald
1. Easy: Hit up the Cinct, call in two BPs, medium rare, the night’s ours. Then head to 5th and Vine for a leisurely stroll under the lights.
2. No question about it, we were meant for each other. We caught each other’s eyes and it was love at first sight. Trust me, it happened.
3. Don’t Stop Believing/Journey – This is exactly how we met, if you use your imagination. i think of Sarah Baby every time i hear that beautiful song.
4. Man, there’s so many options. Probably that awesome diamond necklace at Kay Jewelers. Don’t worry, I’ve got connections.
5. What can I say? We’re simply in love. This was meant for us. True love will always find a way.

Sarah:

1. Medium rare is way too bloody..grody!
2. He definitely caught my eye, but I’m not entirely sold on the whole love-at-first-sight thing.
3. Love. That. Song.
4. Every kiss does begin with Kay!
5. So cliche, but I’m a sucker for romance!

Chris Comisar:
1. Dinner and a movie.
2. I’m just a stud.
3. Taylor Swift  “You Belong to Me”… duh…
4. $20…
5. Because I’m a winner, and winners get what they want.

Sarah:

1. As long as we can see a “chick flick”, I’m game.
2. I am attracted to studs.
3. You can’t go wrong with T. Swift.
4. Great idea! I won’t have to pretend I like it if I hate it.
5. I tend to root for the underdog…

Joel Beeby:
1. Probably Skype her. Ask her “what’s up.” She’ll say “not much.” Things will get really romantic from there when I say “me either.”
2. My Farmville farm has over 600 different plant varieties and 1300 cows. I make 10 gold coins a day, so basically I’m loaded.
3. Probably the song “Paparazzi” by Lady Gaga because my Farmville how-to videos on YouTube have over 500 views, making me famous. With fame comes a cult paparazzi-esque following, and I have so many girls wanting to be my Farmville neighbors (two at the moment!) that she’ll have to “chase [me] down til [she] loves me.”
4. I would use it to buy her some Farmville items so that she can start making gold coins as well, which look great on other people’s news feeds.
5. Why do I deserve a rose? I don’t really, I already have 45 plots dedicated to red roses on Farmville, and their growth cycle is only one day, so I have roses anytime I need them. Once she chooses me and follows my how-to Farmville videos, she will have all the roses she wants and there won’t be a need to give away only one rose.

Sarah:

1. I don’t have Skype so this date wouldn’t work.
2. I’ve never been on Farmville, but that seems pretty impressive.
3. Lady Gaga is overrated.
4. See number 2.
5. See number 2 and 4…no Farmville.

Ben Gorman:
1. I’d take her to an Italian restaurant (Italy is pretty romantic) with soft music in the background that gives off a feel of faraway lands.
2. I will soothe your heartache and show you what you have been missing your 4 years of high school. When you are sad I will cheer you up with a song or perhaps a joke. When you are lonely, I will give you company. I will be there.
3. “You Belong to Me”- Taylor Swift, because what she has been looking for has been here the whole time (me).
4. Bath salts… girls love bath salts.
5. Without a rose, the right man will be out first round. I’m in it for as long as it counts.

Sarah:

1. That sounds like a lovely idea.
2. This is too sweet! Definitely bachelorette material.
3. You really can’t go wrong with Taylor.
4. Bath salts kind of gross me out…
5. I don’t know what to say to this haha.

Jacob Davis:
1.On the first day with the bachelorette I would take her out to dinner and then talk about any of her past relationships and why didn’t they work.
2. I’m the right man for the bachelorette because I’m handsome, admirable, aristocratic, and athletic.
3. The song that I would say that describes me and the bachelorette relationship is Luther Vandross “If Only for One Night”.
4. With twenty dollars I would buy the bachelorette a bracelet that she would remember me by.
5. I deserve the rose because the bachelorette deserves a man who knows how to treat a woman and will do anything to impress her.

Sarah:

1. I don’t really like talking about past relationships, especially on the first date.
2. Those are all great qualities!
3. I don’t think I’ve heard that song.
4. I wear bracelets every day so that’s an amazing idea!
5. Yes I do..great answer!

Hans Hinebaugh:
1. Definitely have to start at Terry’s Turf Club, then head to downtown Cincinnati, but I’m not sure what to do from there. It’s her choice. But first of all I would have to meet her…
2. Why not? I’m so young and youthful. Only problem is I still have to meet her, but I’ve heard people saying her name before.
3. If you ask Sarah, she’ll probably say it’s soon to be the Elvis classic “Burning Love.” I guess I agree with her. I’m pretty sure it’ll eventually be “Let’s Get it On” by Marvin Gaye.
4. Either give her the $20 or get her a dog.
5. Not sure if I actually deserve the rose because I’ve never done anything, but I’d sure take it.

Sarah:

1. Terry’s is always delicious, but I’d say it’s more of a third date kind of place.
2. Emphasis on the “young”…I’m a little sad he doesn’t know who I am.
3. That’s a bit too forward for me.
4. I already have three dogs, but the $20 would be a nice gift.
5. At least he’s honest.

Sarah’s Final Decision:

I’d have to eliminate Chris because he didn’t put very much effort into his answers which makes me think he isn’t as invested in this process as I am. Also, I’d have to eliminate Joel. He is a great guy, but I don’t have Skype or Farmville so I’m not sure how well the relationship would work.